Sep 25

Alderson: Swing And A Miss

Yesterday, I looked at GM Sandy Alderson’s best moves with the Mets. Today, I’ll examine some of his worst decisions, of which there have been more than a few.

Not every decision will work, but here are his swings-and-misses:

INACTIVITIY IN THE OFFSEASON AND TRADE DEADLINE: Several big names have come and gone without Alderson taking a whiff during his tenure. However, it must be remembered the decision not to spend big bucks came from the Wilpons. Quite simply, for the most part he was following instructions. Still, there have been several middle-tier free agents that might have helped such as Jason Marquis.

ALDERSON: Not everything went perfectly.

ALDERSON: Not everything went perfectly.

FAILURE TO BUILD BULLPEN: Alderson’s primary building objective since his arrival was to build a bullpen. It hasn’t worked out, although this year’s pen – if kept intact – has the potential to be good. They finally settled on a role for Jenrry Mejia and he’s developed into a quality closer.

Arguably, one of Alderson’s best pick-ups – and I should have mentioned this yesterday – is Carlos Torres. Jeurys Familia, Vic Black, Rafael Montero and Josh Edgin comprise a quality core with a lot of potential. Still, it took up to three years for Alderson to get the bullpen going in the right direction.

THE OUTFIELD:  Remember when Lucas Duda, Mike Baxter and Jordany Valdespin were in the outfield? Players have come and gone but Alderson has never put together a good outfield. At least, for the next few years he’ll have Juan Lagares and Curtis Granderson. But, there’s still a hole in left field.

CHRIS YOUNG: Paying $7.25 million for one year for a .200 hitter. Yes, that’s what he did. He was hoping to strike lightning in a bottle, but he could have taken that gamble for half that amount.

IKE DAVIS: Alderson tried the patience route far long with first baseman Ike Davis. Last season never should have happened.

JORDANY VALDESPIN: Alderson finally did the right thing, but Alderson should have cut ties with him last summer. You don’t let that kind of that distraction fester on a team trying to adapt a new culture.

NOT PUSHING THE ENVELOPE WITH THE INJURED: Matt Harvey and David Wright, to name two, were those who played while injured and subsequently missed the rest of the season. Particularly Wright has persisted and play through injuries.

 

Dec 16

Second base situation a good sign

It’s a good sign when Terry Collins said the Mets’ second base job is wide open on several fronts, perhaps most importantly because it signals a willingness to cut ties with Luis Castillo if he doesn’t carry his own weight.

If the Mets aren’t able to swing a deal – and who really expects that to happen? – then a willingness to eat the $6 million contract is a positive development.

As of now, Daniel Murphy, Rule 5 pickup from Toronto Brad Emaus, Castillo, and Justin Turner will be in the mix. Minus will be Ruben Tejada, who showed he could do the job with his glove but not the bat.

Murphy probably has the most potential obviously, but is learning the position. Emaus must remain on the 25-man roster or be returned to the Blue Jays, but the Mets have so many holes that carrying a utility infielder might be a reach.

That could mean Turner could slot in as a sleeper.

The encouraging thing to me is that if Castillo doesn’t earn the job outright, that the Mets are now willing to cut their losses. They’ll still pay the money, but would rid themselves of a non-productive player.

And, hopefully, that will follow through with Oliver Perez. Keep a good thought.

Aug 26

Mets Chat Room; gotta get Reyes moving.

If the Mets are to go on this miracle run, they’ll need to get Jose Reyes again, beginning tonight with Florida. The Mets are at their best when he gets on and makes things happen.

Game #127 vs. Marlins

He’s cooled off since his 15-for-31 road trip Houston and Pittsburgh, going 0-for-10 in the first two games of the Marlins’ series.

He was 0-for-5 last night and grounded out with the bases loaded to end the game.

“I tried to get a base hit or walk, something to tie the game or win the game,’’ Reyes said. “He made a quality pitch on me and got me out. I saw it good, but I wasn’t able to put my best swing on that ball.’’

There’s been discussions about picking up Reyes’ option and negotiate an extension. There’s also been talks in the media if the best thing to do would be to trade him for a package of prospects.

Personally, I’d keep Reyes. You’re not going to find anybody that will produce like him.

NOTE: Folks I have to work tonight and won’t be able to monitor the board. I hope you’ll pop in with your comments.

Aug 06

A weekend in Philadelphia

This should be a big series tonight in Philadelphia. There should be a tenseness in the air, a feeling of excitement and anticipation that comes with a pennant race.

But, there is no fire. After the Mets fell flat and were routed by Arizona last Sunday, they sleepwalked through Atlanta. Take away one swing of the bat by Jeff Francoeur and they would be heading to Philly on a four-game losing streak.

Not only were the Mets sloppy in Atlanta, but worse they were listless and seemed disinterested. With the exception of R.A. Dickey (and Johan Santana after the first inning Monday), they played flat and without a sense of urgency.

Their season is hanging on by a thread and they are playing with an aura of inevitability, as if they were waiting for the end.

It could be soon enough.

Jul 16

Plenty of blame to go around on Reyes fiasco.

REYES: On the shelf.

Maybe this time they are getting it right.

Better late than never, but the Mets say they are now shutting down Jose Reyes until he’s able to swing pain free from both sides of the plate. The decision came as the outcome of last night’s pre-game circus that first had Reyes in the lineup, and then scratched with the news he’ll be put on the shelf.

The ringmaster of the circus, of course, is Jerry Manuel, who has irresponsibly bungled this from the outset.

Continue reading