It is clear Juan Lagares is currently out of favor with the Mets, but I don’t believe the situation is permanent. As the Mets currently express limited interest in bringing back Yoenis Cespedes on a short-term deal – some reports have it as short as one season – I keep thinking perhaps the best option is to go with the guy already on a multi-year deal.
The Mets gave Lagares a five-year deal because they liked his speed and glove, and were optimistic about his offensive potential. While Lagares regressed in 2015 in all areas, I wonder how much was his elbow; was hitting the sophomore slump; or maybe the Mets misjudged him.
Perhaps it is a combination of all three. Perhaps it was just a bad year.
Whatever the reasons, the Mets remain on the hook for the remaining four years. I’ve written several times the deal was currently a bust. I still think that way at times, but my overriding thought is what if Lagares eventually lives up to what the Mets envisioned for him?
If that is the case, it would be best if they find out about him sooner than later. I’m not holding out any hope they’ll rope in Cespedes for one or even four years. The Mets gave Wilmer Flores a chance last season, and did the same with Michael Conforto, as well as young pitchers Noah Syndergaard and Steven Matz.
So, why not the same with Lagares?
If he outperforms the competition during spring training, then let him play full time. Give him up to two months, or possibly until the All-Star break. If the Mets are in the race at the trade deadline, perhaps they can swing a deal.
But, what if Lagares has a breakout year? It’s worth a chance to find out.