R.A. Dickey was a feel-good story for the 2010 Mets, but not good enough where his dancing knuckleball will warrant a multi-year deal.
At 36 and coming off a career-best 11-9 season, Dickey is seeking a two-year contract, but among the arbitration eligible Mets, the one most likely to get a multi-year extension is Mike Pelfrey. The Mets will play hardball with Dickey, who has a career 33-37 record.
Dickey did a remarkable job in a patchwork role in the rotation after Oliver Perez and John Maine flamed out. He was a major reason why the Mets were competitive in the early part of the season. Unquestionably, he deserves a spot in the rotation entering spring training, but his age and career record will preclude the Mets from doing more than arbitration.
And, they shouldn’t, either.
Dickey was good last year, but still not much more than a .500 pitcher. The Mets have been through this before, being seduced by one good season and rewarding with a multi-year extension. What if Dickey turned out to be a fluke? The last thing they need is to be saddled with an unproductive contract.
As much as the Mets need pitching, making a gamble investment for 2012 isn’t a good idea.